posted 9th December 2025
Can HMRC Prosecute Me? Civil vs Criminal Tax Investigations Explained for UK Taxpayers
HMRC operates both civil and criminal investigation routes. Most taxpayers initially fall under civil investigation, but cases can escalate to criminal where HMRC believes serious fraud has occurred.
Civil investigations aim to recover unpaid tax, interest, and penalties. Criminal investigations seek prosecution and can result in fines, asset confiscation, and imprisonment.
Factors that increase the likelihood of criminal prosecution include:
- Deliberate falsification of records
- Use of offshore structures to conceal income
- Repeated non-compliance
- Obstruction of HMRC officers
- Evidence of organised fraud
Get Civil And Criminal Tax Investigation Advice Today
Behaviour after discovery is also critical. Attempts to destroy records, mislead investigators, or move assets after enquiry often shift cases into the criminal arena.
Criminal investigations involve:
- Search warrants
- Interviews under caution
- Asset restraint orders
- Confiscation proceedings
The vast majority of taxpayers do not face prosecution, but poor handling of early civil enquiries is one of the most common reasons cases escalate. Early specialist representation protects legal rights, controls evidence flow, and significantly reduces the risk of criminal outcomes.
HMRC issues letters to thousands of people each year, but how you respond can determine the entire outcome. Before you say or send anything, speak to Tax Investigation Helpline. Our expert advisors specialise solely in HMRC investigations and know precisely how to reduce risk, defend your position, and secure the best possible outcome.
